Which mattress is better, spring or springless - compare the orthopedic effect

• 1 Characteristics of spring and springless mattresses
• 2 Types of spring mattresses 2.1 Pros and cons:
• 2.2 Cost

For proper sleep and rest, a sense of vigor in the morning, and the absence of muscle pain, you need a good bed equipped with a properly selected mattress. Today there are two main types of mattresses – spring and springless. Each of them has a number of advantages and disadvantages. A wide range of fillers, types of rigidity and a variety of designs makes the choice difficult and ambiguous. But a thorough study of the properties and characteristics, advice from orthopedic doctors will help to understand this problem and better understand which mattress, spring or springless?

A wide range of fillers, types of rigidity and a variety of designs makes the choice difficult and ambiguous.

Characteristics of spring and springless mattresses

The production of mattresses is a developed industry, so domestic and foreign companies put forward many proposals, from the simplest, budget ones to advanced products that can be remotely switched to a sitting position, turned on a massage function, or programmed as an alarm clock. Consumer models are not equipped with such “smart” characteristics, but they differ significantly in orthopedic properties, pricing policy and provide different sleep comfort. A person spends more than 2,300 hours a year in bed, so it is important to choose a mattress that guarantees good rest. To decide on a model, you first need to study all the properties of existing mattresses.

A person spends more than 2,300 hours a year in bed, so it is important to choose a mattress that guarantees good rest.

Types of spring mattresses

Mattresses based on springs are divided into two groups - with dependent or independent spring blocks:

• In products where the block is dependent, such as “Bonnell”, all springs are tightly attached to each other, due to which the product is equally rigid over the entire area. In the line of mattresses, this type has long been considered obsolete due to its fragility - the springs quickly become unsteady, even with careful handling, and begin to deform and creak. The model is still in demand due to its budget price.

All springs are tightly attached to each other, making the product equally rigid over the entire area.

• Inside the mattress, where the block has an independent pattern of springs, they are not fastened together, but are placed, each in its own case. Such mattresses are produced in different levels of hardness and even combine several in one product. The number of rigid zones of one mattress can reach 9. The design is made in such a way that it effectively supports the spine, literally envelops the body, which creates comfort during sleep. When one person makes a movement, the vibrations are not transmitted to the person sleeping nearby. Quality, price and comfort during sleep depend on the number of springs placed per square meter. The mark starts at 256, a good mattress already contains 512 springs, and expensive, elite models consist of 1000-2000 separate springs.

The design is made in such a way that it effectively supports the spine, literally envelops the body, thereby creating comfort during sleep.

If you turn the mattress over two or three times a year, this will significantly extend its service life and allow the sides that are not in use to gradually recover one by one.

Advantages and disadvantages:

• Models of sleeping accessories with a block of independent springs have orthopedic properties, supporting the spinal column in the required position. The next morning a person feels cheerful and rested.
• Such mattresses are absolutely silent thanks to the fabric upholstery of each individual spring, which, when in contact with each other, do not create a creak.
• High-quality mattresses are sold at a high price, which is not affordable for everyone, but they are quite durable if handled carefully.

Models of sleeping accessories with a block of independent springs have orthopedic properties, supporting the spinal column in the required position.

Price

A mattress for one bed, consisting of independent spring blocks, will cost the buyer 10-20 thousand rubles, based on the number of springs. You need to save 20-50 thousand in national currency for a double model.

A quality and reliable mattress will be worth a good investment.

Varieties depending on the filler

The comfort of using a mattress is affected by the filler. Products are divided into several types, each of which has its own characteristics. The choice depends on the price category and individual preferences.

Polyurethane foam

An artificial material often called artificial latex. Such mattresses are durable and follow all the curves and contours of the body. Among the advantages it is worth highlighting the following:

• hypoallergenic;
• relatively low price, due to which the models are popular among buyers;
• breathability;
• good orthopedic characteristics.

Minuses:

• the duration of use is lower than that of natural latex;
• the material absorbs moisture well, which can result in problems with drying.

Natural latex

It is made exclusively from natural raw materials. The higher the concentration of latex in the filler, the higher its cost.

Advantages of the material:

• hypoallergenic, it does not cause irritation;
• dust does not accumulate inside, which prevents the emergence and spread of dust mites;
• due to the existing pores, the model provides excellent ventilation;
• has moderate elasticity;
• ensures the correct position of the sleeping body;
• does not absorb moisture;
• durable;
• able to withstand high loads.

Among the disadvantages is the high cost. Due to this, few people can afford to purchase the product, but the positive characteristics justify the money spent.

Struttofiber

The material includes two parts:

• strutto is an Italian technology that designates the vertical arrangement of product components;
• fiber - fiber.

The following advantages of the material are highlighted:

• does not absorb moisture;
• durable and does not rot;
• does not cause allergies;
• prevents the proliferation and appearance of dust mites;
• doesn't creak.

Flaws:

• deforms under prolonged loads;
• cannot be folded or folded, as the structure changes;
• short-lived compared to latex.

Coconut coir

Coconut fiber is intended for mattresses with a high degree of rigidity. It is often used in mattresses for newborns. In addition, hard surfaces are useful for those who suffer from spinal diseases.

Pros of use:

• ventilation;
• presence of hygroscopic properties;
• does not cause allergies.

Disadvantages include instability to kinks. Products made from such material cannot be rolled.

Springless mattresses

According to their structure, mattresses are divided into 3 types:

• monolithic - the block consists of one type of filler;
• combined - the base of which is a solid canvas, supplemented on both sides with several balls of another material to achieve a certain effect;
• puff - made from alternately laid layers of the same width 3-4 cm.

The density and strength of the product is ensured by overlapping layers of different combinations of fillers. Due to the order of layers, different levels of rigidity are achieved: soft, medium-hard and hard.

Due to the order of layers, different levels of rigidity are achieved: soft, medium-hard and hard.

The most common and popular filler for springless mattresses is latex. If it is obtained from the sap of the Hevea tree, known as the rubber tree, it is considered natural and the safest for human health. Latex filler can also be artificial.

The most common and popular filler for springless mattresses is latex.

Coconut coir mattresses are moisture-resistant and well ventilated, but the material makes them hard. They are usually bought for children whose posture is just developing or for adults with spinal problems, as prescribed by their doctors.

Coconut coir mattresses are moisture-resistant and well ventilated, but the material makes them hard.

Polyurethane foam is a more advanced classic foam rubber. This filling is considered a budget analogue of expensive latex. But such mattresses are not endowed with orthopedic properties. There are two options for this filling: standard and cast furniture. The first one has low performance characteristics, quickly fails and requires replacement. The second, on the contrary, is dense, elastic and does not deteriorate over time, although it may bend slightly in the center if an overweight body sleeps on the bed.

Polyurethane foam is a more advanced classic foam rubber.

Struttofiber is a popular artificial component of the mattress base. This is a packing with vertical fibers, which ensures unobstructed air ventilation. The material does not rot and has a long service life. At the same time, various additives provide a comfortable sleep temperature: down and wool give a feeling of warmth, and linen, on the contrary, provides coolness.

Struttofiber is a popular artificial component of the mattress base.

There is also a high-tech filler developed in NASA laboratories more than half a century ago, but only recently coming into widespread use - Memory Foam or a foam-like thermoelastic structure with memory properties. The mattress completely remembers the structure of the body, which makes rest comfortable and easily restores the surface after the sleeper gets out of bed.

It completely remembers the structure of the body, which makes rest comfortable and easily restores the surface after the sleeper gets out of bed.

Advantages and disadvantages

• There are no parts in such a mattress that can deteriorate or break, so the products are durable.
• The design eliminates the appearance of any noise.
• Excellent orthopedic properties help support the health of the spine, cervical spine and lower back.
• Mattresses are hypoallergenic, do not rot, and prevent the formation of fungi and mold.
• The high price of products makes them inaccessible to buyers with little income. If funds for purchasing a mattress are strictly limited, you should take a closer look at artificial fillers, thanks to which you can significantly save on your purchase.
• For such mattresses there are weight recommendations, so the strongest model will not support more than 140 kg. On average, the ceiling weight is limited to 120 kg.

Choose a mattress after weighing all the pros and cons.

Price

The cost of a combined mattress for one bed, filled with latex and coir, starts from 15 thousand rubles, for two beds - from 22 thousand. A filler made of synthetic latex and coconut fiber will be 3-4 thousand rubles cheaper. The most expensive material is memory foam, so the price of such products starts from 24 thousand for one bed and from 60 thousand for a double size.

Just as in the previous case with spring models, a good springless mattress will cost a pretty penny.

Rating of orthopedic mattress manufacturers

The rating of the best products is made by the buyers themselves. Before purchasing a mattress, read reviews from users. Stores that respect their customers do not hide negative feedback. And they can give you a complete picture of the quality and ease of use of the mattress. We have already noted that there is no clear answer to the question of which mattress is better - spring or springless. It all depends on your requirements, preferences and financial capabilities. But you can find the answer to the question of which company is better to buy a mattress. We analyzed the product ratings for you according to Yandex.Market data, and this is what happened:

5th place – “Comfort Line”

It was included in the rating of the best for its high assessment of springless models. They are comfortable and have a long service life. The manufacturer uses different types of fillers. The only nuance that users note is the smell that is present in the first months after purchasing the mattress.

Model “Comfort Line Roll Classic”

4th place – “Ormatek”

Domestic uses the most advanced technologies borrowed from developers from the USA and Europe. Ormatek factories produce spring and springless products. Particular attention is paid to the possibility of air exchange and hygiene of mattresses.

Mattress Ormatek Flex Strong

3rd place – “Beautyson”

Combined products made of latex and pocket springs have become leaders of this manufacturer. The absence of toxic glue and high quality material make Beautyson mattresses very popular in our market. There are many positive reviews about the products of this company from people with large weights.

Beautyson Baby Elite mattress

2nd place – “Ascona”

This brand is heard by almost everyone. "Ascona" offers a wide selection of not only spring beds, but also orthopedic pillows. Many users ask which mattresses are better - “Ascona” or “Ormatek”? Both of these manufacturers guarantee high quality products, but, perhaps, Askona stands out with its special patented anti-deformation system, which keeps the bed in its original condition for a long time.

IMPRESSION PLUS mattress

1st place – “Magniflex”

Magniflex won this rating in a difficult battle with Ascona, but it was this manufacturer that the majority of Yandex Market visitors gave their votes to. The most comfortable mattresses are produced in Italy. They are distinguished by a special “memory” system - the surface of the berth fixes a position that is comfortable for you. All mattresses have two working sides - for cool and hot seasons, this is very convenient. The price for such models is rather high, but believe me, they are worth it.

Magniflex Stretching 9 mattress

The difference between spring and springless mattresses

1. The service life of a good spring mattress is 10 years, and a latex mattress will retain its original qualities for up to 15 years.
2. Lying on a spring mattress is always more comfortable; it is much softer than a springless one.
3. Static electricity has no positive effect on the body and is present only in spring mattresses that contain metal parts. It also occurs due to mattress covers made from synthetic materials.
4. In models with dependent and independent springs, dust gradually accumulates in technical voids and leads to the appearance of linen mites, which can subsequently cause serious allergic reactions. Springless mattresses do not have this problem. Microorganisms and insects do not live in natural latex and coir.
5. Once on the surface of a springless mattress, moisture gradually evaporates without harming it. The same cannot be said about models with springs. Moisture getting inside leads to corrosion of elements, their further deformation and an unpleasant squeak that interferes with sleep.
6. On a spring mattress, not the entire surface area is used; during sleep, a person, as it were, finds himself in a hole, or a hammock, formed under the weight of the body. On a springless mattress, the entire fabric is fully used.

To make the right choice, you need to weigh all the pros and cons.

Characteristics of a quality model

In principle, a comfortable, durable sleeping surface can be found among both. True, there are cases when it is better to choose a specific option. But, regardless of this, a good mattress should have a number of general characteristics.

• Dimensions. As for the length, it is considered comfortable if it exceeds the height of the sleeper by at least 15 cm. A comfortable width for one person is 80 cm. The thickness should correspond to the weight of the sleeper. At the same time, a thicker mattress is required for the same weight if it is a spring type.
• Safety. Inexpensive models from little-known manufacturers quite often use toxic fillers that can harm our health for years by releasing harmful substances into the air. A pungent chemical smell from a mattress is the first sign that it is an unhealthy fake.
• Hypoallergenic. This factor is especially important for people prone to allergies. Allergenic materials can be either synthetic (for example, low-quality polyurethane foam) or natural (wool).
• Hygienic properties. A good mattress must be ventilated, that is, allow air to pass through, otherwise it can mold or rust and become a source of bacteria. Also, high-quality models are usually impregnated with special moisture- and dirt-repellent substances.
• Comfort. For older people, softer mattresses are more comfortable; for people with lower back pain, too; if there are problems with the cervical spine, it is better to choose a firmer option. But regardless of whether the model is soft or hard, spring or springless, the person sleeping on it should be comfortable.

How to determine which mattress is suitable, spring or springless, tips and opinions

Each line of mattresses has its own advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, when choosing the right model, it is worth taking into account weight, height, and the condition of the vertebral bones:

• For overweight people weighing more than 100 kg, it is preferable to choose hard fillers; they will not sag much and will more effectively support posture.
• For adults under 50 kg, soft mattresses are suitable, regardless of type.
• Children are recommended to purchase hard models for two reasons. The formation of the baby's bones is not yet complete, so proper placement during rest is required, which can be provided by a hard mattress. Children are active, love to play and jump, but a mattress of medium or soft hardness may simply not withstand the load.
• For older people, mattresses with springs in independent blocks of medium hardness are suitable.
• It is even more difficult for young and healthy people to make a choice - for them any average type of mattress will be equally good.

When choosing the right model, it is worth taking into account weight, height, and the condition of the vertebral bones.
Before such an expensive purchase, it is better to consult and get recommendations from an orthopedic doctor. Based on a specific case, he will point out the most suitable model and the money will not be thrown away. This is especially true for those who have problems with the musculoskeletal system or the cardiovascular system.

Before such an expensive purchase, it is better to consult and get recommendations from an orthopedic doctor.

According to user reviews and opinions of orthopedic doctors, springless mattresses consisting of combined layers have the best characteristics. Alternating different fillers helps achieve optimal rigidity. Universal types combine several zones of rigidity, for example, they are hard in the middle and soft at the edges, which makes the product as effective as possible and ensures complete comfort of sleep and rest.

Alternating different fillers helps achieve optimal rigidity.

Summing up

There is an opinion that a properly selected mattress is already 70% of a good sleep. If you buy a product from trusted manufacturers with a good reputation, in stores that have inspection models and specialists who are competent in selecting the best option, healthy and complete rest will be ensured.

By choosing the best option for yourself, a healthy and complete rest will be ensured.

How to choose a model “for yourself”

Choosing the right springless mattress is a subjective and highly individual matter. When choosing it, you must first of all focus on your own feelings. Here's what the experts recommend:

• For a person with an average build, it is best to choose a medium-hard model that has a layer of coconut coir or latex;
• for those who are well-fed, a hard product with coconut coir is recommended;
• For thin people, a soft mattress, such as latex, is suitable.